I used to think Christmas could survive anything if there was enough food on the table and enough people pretending not to notice the cracks. In our house in Phibsborough, my mam would light the good candles, my dad would put on The Pogues, and my sister would arrive late with a bag of presents and an apology she never meant. It was messy, loud, imperfect, but it was ours. Then I brought home the wrong man, or maybe the right man at the wrong time.
I was twenty-nine and working in a café near Temple Bar when I met Conor. He was charming in a way that made you feel chosen. He remembered how I took my coffee, held doors open, and texted after dates instead of disappearing into that fog people call “being busy.” By November, I was mad about him. I invited him to our Christmas dinner before I had fully admitted to myself that I was in love.
The problem was Aoife. She had been my best friend since first year in school, the kind of friend who knew every version of me and still answered the phone. She had dated Conor years before, briefly, or so she said. When I told her his full name, she went quiet on the other end of the line. Then she laughed too loudly and said Dublin was too small for anyone to have a clean past.
I should have asked more questions. Instead, I accepted the version that allowed me to keep everyone. Aoife said she was fine. Conor said it had been nothing. I wanted my life to be simple, so I believed them both.
On Christmas Eve, we went for drinks in Stoneybatter. The place was all fairy lights and steamed-up windows, everyone softened by pints and the promise of going home. Aoife arrived in a red coat, beautiful and sharp, and Conor looked at her for half a second too long. It was so quick I almost missed it, but my stomach didn’t. The body knows before the mind is willing.
Later, outside the pub, I found them speaking near the smoking area. Not touching. Not doing anything I could accuse them of. But they had the posture of people standing in the ruins of something. Aoife’s eyes were wet. Conor looked guilty, not surprised. When they saw me, they both stopped talking, and that silence did more damage than any confession could have.
I still brought him to dinner the next day. That is the part I find hardest to forgive in myself. I put on a green dress, wrapped my presents, and told myself I would not let suspicion ruin Christmas. My mam hugged Conor at the door and called him lovely. My dad poured him whiskey. Aoife came because she always came; she had nowhere else she wanted to be, and my family had become partly hers over the years.
Dinner began normally. Too many potatoes, my dad overcooking the turkey, my mam asking Conor questions as if interviewing him for the role of future son-in-law. Aoife was quiet. Conor was careful. I drank wine too quickly and laughed at things that weren’t funny.
It happened during dessert. My sister, who had the tact of a dropped pan, made a joke about how strange it was that I had ended up with Aoife’s ex. My mam’s hand froze over the trifle. My dad looked from one face to another. I asked Aoife, calmly at first, to explain why everyone seemed to know more than I did.
Aoife started crying. Conor closed his eyes. And there it was, on Christmas Day, between the pudding and the tea: they had not dated briefly. They had been together for nearly two years. They had lived in a flat off Camden Street. They had talked about marriage. He had left her suddenly, without giving her a proper ending. When he met me, he recognised my name and knew who I was to her, but said nothing because he “didn’t want to lose me before we began.”
I remember the sound my chair made when I stood up. I remember my mam saying my name like she could catch me with it. I remember Aoife reaching for my hand and me pulling away. What hurt most was not that they had loved each other. People have histories. What destroyed me was that both of them had trusted my ignorance more than my heart.
Christmas ended in fragments. Conor left before the tea was poured. Aoife walked home in the rain though my dad offered to drive her. My mam cried while wrapping leftovers in foil. My sister kept saying she was sorry, which somehow made me angrier. By eight o’clock, the tree lights were
Note: Please be aware that these are written in confidentiality and there is not reference or mention of any real people and their sentiments here. Every incident and Story tends to be emotional so please read at your own emotional risk. Website is not responsible for anything related. HumansofDublin.io is not related to the photography project HumansofDublin by Peter Varga
